日本語道場

Nihongo Dojo — N3 → N2

Grammar

N2

~ともなく

~to mo naku / ~to mo nashi ni

without particular intention

When to use it

Use ~ともなく when describing an action done absent-mindedly, with no real intention or focus — typically perception verbs (見る・聞く・考える). In writing it lends a literary, reflective tone, so it appears in narrative passages, essays and the descriptive parts of reports rather than in direct business speech. The related pattern 疑問詞+から/ともなく (誰からともなく, どこからともなく) means "from no particular source", which is common even in fairly neutral written business Japanese.

Formation

  • Verbs: dictionary form + ともなく/ともなしに(見るともなく、聞くともなしに)。Very often the same verb is repeated: 見るともなく見る。
  • Question words: 疑問詞+(助詞)+ともなく(誰からともなく、どこからともなく、いつからともなく)。
  • i-adjectives / na-adjectives / nouns: not used. (Do not confuse with the concessive ~とも/~ともあろう.)
  • Register: ともなしに is the more literary variant; ともなく is the standard written form.

Examples

  • Applause broke out from no one in particular, and the meeting ended.

  • The director half-listened to my report without really taking it in.

  • Rumours of a price hike spread through the company from nowhere in particular.

  • Staring blankly at the email on screen, I thought about my reply.

  • At some point or other, this practice had become established.